| Key Points: – Investors anticipate a 50 basis point rate cut in September due to weakening job market data. – A larger cut may signal recession fears, not inflation control, spurring market sell-offs. – The current economic “soft landing” could be a temporary illusion as the labor market weakens. |
The market is abuzz with speculation that the Federal Reserve might deliver a larger-than-expected interest rate cut in September, driven by recent signs of economic softness. While many investors are hoping for a 50 basis point cut, especially after the latest JOLTS report showing the lowest job openings since 2021, they may want to be cautious. A deeper rate cut isn’t necessarily the good news it might seem on the surface.
The JOLTS data, coupled with last month’s jobs report, has raised concerns that the labor market could be weakening more rapidly than anticipated. Investors are now looking to Friday’s employment numbers with increased apprehension, and Fed fund futures are reflecting expectations of a significant rate cut at the Federal Reserve’s next meeting. But before the market gets too excited about the prospect of lower rates, it’s important to consider the message a large cut would send.
A 50 basis point cut would likely indicate that the Federal Reserve is more worried about a looming recession than ongoing inflation. According to David Sekera, Morningstar’s chief US market strategist, such a cut could trigger an even deeper stock market sell-off. The move would suggest that the Fed sees significant risks to the economy, much like a pilot deploying oxygen masks in mid-flight—hardly a signal of smooth skies ahead.
Other experts are also expressing caution. Citi’s chief US economist Andrew Hollenhorst points out that the market seems to be in denial about the growing signs of labor market weakness, just as it was slow to accept the seriousness of inflation during its early stages. Hollenhorst emphasizes that the unemployment rate has been gradually rising for months now, not just a one-off event. This slow deterioration suggests the labor market is indeed weakening, and a larger rate cut could be the Fed’s acknowledgment of that fact.
While moderating inflation does provide the Fed with some breathing room to focus on supporting the economy, the idea that the economy is still in a “Goldilocks” phase—where inflation is cooling, and the job market remains resilient—might be wishful thinking. Investors should be careful what they wish for when it comes to monetary policy, as the short-term benefits of lower rates could be overshadowed by the reality of a deeper economic slowdown.
